April 04, 2009

Phil Watch: I Throw Up My Arms

If a sportswriter plans to write an evaluation of a shift in a team's roster towards pitching and defense, you'd think that the end product would be filled with correct facts and stuff of that nature, right?

Well...you know.  This is the Chicago Tribune.  Only yesterday, Vaughn McClure wrote an article asking, "Is coming of Jay Cutler to Chicago Bears heaven-sent?"  And Rick Morrissey (BRETOA3 participant) called the Jay Cutler signing a bad move.  So...

But it's refreshing to know that Phil still possesses the ability to write something even more stupid than those.  At least those guys were simply making judgments.  Wrong judgments but merely judgments all the same.

Phil, in evaluating the Tigers roster moves, makes wrong judgments AND gets basic facts wrong.

Let's get started.

This time last spring, when the buzz around baseball was the muscle in the Detroit Tigers' lineup, some of us rejected the hype.

Courtesy of South Side Sox

Phil rejected the hype with extreme prejudice!  Oh...wait.

You don't overcome a flawed, fragile pitching staff and second-division fielding with a collection of hitters. Teams almost never slug their way to titles. The Tigers have realized that, and that's why Gary Sheffield isn't with them anymore.

Thank you, Captain Obvious.  

And read that again.  Using that logic, teams should dump all of their aging sluggers.  Just write that Leyland and Sheffield didn't like each other, Sheffield wouldn't have shut up about playing the field so they dumped his mouthy, bad fielding ass.

The Tigers aren't competing for anything this year.  They're going young, trying different things, will be extraordinarily active at the deadline and that's why they dumped him.  Write that.

General manager Dave Dombrowski has given manager Jim Leyland a team that will do a much better job catching the ball...

Dombrowski started retooling the Tigers' defense with the signing of fielding-first shortstop Adam Everett and the trade for catcher Gerald Laird. Those moves set Brandon Inge at third base, where he played when Detroit went to the 2006 World Series, and moved the error-prone Carlos Guillen to left field.


Adam Everett?  Great fielder.  And one of the worst offensive players in baseball.  I mean, he's absolutely terrible. 

Laird?  He's the definition of average behind the plate while forcing two guys into the lineup when you include Inge on a regular basis who are well below-average hitters.

And Guillen in left?  Phil predicts that to go well? 

By writing off Sheffield as $38 million poorly spent, the Tigers create a revolving door at DH. Guillen may get most of the time there, but Magglio Ordonez also will fill that hole sometimes, with the consistently underrated Marcus Thames getting the outfield starts.

BAAAAAAHHHHH!!!!  Marcus Thames throws crap leather at a wildly prodigious rate.  Really.  How does a major league baseball player have a -29.3 UZR150?

If he qualifed, Thames would have been the second-worst fielder in all of baseball last year, behind only Brad Hawpe's superlatively crappy -47.9.  That's all fielders, folks.  Not just outfielders.  

Guillen and Thames at the corner outfield spots is Phil's answer to a better Tiger defense.

Jeff Larish, a left-handed hitter who has hit 67 homers in his three full minor-league seasons, takes Sheffield's spot on the roster. The corner infielder can start at first to give Cabrera a chance to get off his feet as the DH.

And struck out 318 times while hitting .255 in 'three full minor-league seasons.'

...Newcomers Edwin Jackson, who was Tampa Bay's No. 5 starter last season, and Rick Porcello, a 20-year-old who hasn't pitched above Class A, join new closer Brandon Lyon as the key guys.

My.  God.  Fernando Rodney was named the Opening Day closer five days ago.  Five!  Read the wire reports, Phil.  

Porcello might be the best pitching prospect to enter the majors since Mark Prior. He has a great collection of pitches, including a 12-to-6 curveball and a hard sinker, and he commands the strike zone.

Is that a joke?  I don't have the time to do all the lists but Porcello was the 7th-best pitching prospect in Baseball America's top 100 list THIS year.  7th-best.  And that leaves out every other year since 2002.  

Tone down the hyperbole.  He had a really good first year in the minors last year, had an admirable GO/FO rate but sure didn't miss a lot of bats.  

"I think he's ready," Dombrowski told the Detroit Free Press. "I think he'll do well. If he has some tough times — every pitcher does — I think he's mature enough to handle it. … He has a pitch that can help get him out of jams — a very, very nasty sinker."

What do you think he's going to say?  Dombrowski has no other options.

Porcello won't be alone in learning the ropes. He's joined by power reliever Ryan Perry, who was pitching for the University of Arizona at this time last season. Dombrowski cites "an electric arm" and mental toughness as reasons for throwing him into the fire alongside Porcello.

See above.  Perry has pitched 13.2 innings of professional baseball.

"Are we right?" Leyland asked. "The easiest thing is to say they're not ready. The way I look at it, they deserve to be on [the team]."

Unlike the addition of Sheffield after the World Series season, these are changes with shelf life.


See.  Not one mention of the tough road ahead this year.  It's a patchwork team getting oodles younger.  Also, not one mention of the Josh Anderson acquisition, a guy who plays great defense, has stolen 40 or more bases in each of the last five seasons and the reason they released Sheffield.

Let's end on the traditional note.

National.  Baseball.  Writer.

March 28, 2009

Phil Watch: Just The Juicy Bits


Mid-week Phil this week in the Trib's Hardball blog.

Why not?

Let's do it just for cataloguing purposes.


FT. MYERS, FLA. -- Is there a player in the majors who means more to his team than Joe Mauer?


I'm not sure there is. 

We covered that.

The Minnesota Twins catcher is a .317 career hitter who bats third, the Donald Trump spot. 

Phil was on the MLB Network a few days ago puking back his Ralph Kramden joke w/r/t Joe Mauer.  Matt Vasgerian thought it was HI-larious!!!  

On that, Vasgerian asked Phil questions relating only to his last few columns, which were almost uniformly Twins-tastic.  Cuz Crede and Mauer are dreamy.

If Mauer is healthy, the Twins should be able to once again compete with anyone in the American League Central, including Detroit and the White Sox, who always outspend them. 

Whoa!  I thought it was the addition of Crede?  From February Phil:
...With Crede migrating from the defending champion Sox, the Twins become favorites to win their fifth division title in eight seasons under the brilliantly simple Ron Gardenhire.
Ron Gardenhire gets that. But after watching Mauer suffer through the pain and confusion of an injury almost never seen in baseball – lower-back pain caused by an inflammation of the sacroiliac joint; the dreaded Ralph Kramden injury – it's clear that the team's plight is a distant second on Gardenhire's radar.

See.  Well, Vasgerian laughed so why not pound the joke into the ground.

And shouldn't Gardenhire be worried about the team first?  It's not like Mauer's going to die.  Aren't they at least interrelated?

The timing is horrible for Mauer. He's due a total of $23 million in the last two seasons of a four-year deal but was poised to start talks on a monster extension – perhaps a deal worth upwards of $100 million – before being sidelined. 

My Golly!  Nobody's giving Mauer $100 million!  A catcher...with a history of various, weird injuries?  Please tell me what team pays that and I will tell you that is a stupid baseball team.

Onto other stuff...

Wringing out the last drops: There's not a lot left in the tank for Jorge Posada and Jason Varitek, not after having putting their bodies on the line these last 11 seasons in the Yankee-Red Sox rivalry.

Oh, God.  He didn't say that.

They hope that 25-year-old George Kottaras will hit enough to prove himself worthy.

Kottaras will get playing time as Varitek's backup, having passed the test of catching Tim Wakefield's knuckleball.


I call for a moratorium on stupid-ass articles breaking down the "importance" of the Red Sox finding a guy to catch Tim Freakin' Wakefield.  My brain can't take it anymore.

And then there's Phil Whispers.  He keeps an ear to the ground...

Korean manager Kim In-sik is one of my new heroes. He watched every game his team played in the WBC with amazingly calm body language, like he had prepared his team and was willing to let the players win or lose. 

Hero?  Wait a minute...is this more "WBC guys are like war heroes" crap?  Like Ted Roosevelt Lilly crap?

But at the same time he made daring tactical decisions that often worked. 

Yep.  He was like the Allied Forces' advance on Guadalcanal.  Stalwart, calm and cool.

News to very few: The Orioles have two young studs in center fielder Adam Jones and catcher Matt Wieters. … 

Then why write it.

It's almost time to make my picks and I still don't know which way to go in the AL Central. I'm pretty well set on the Yankees, Angels, Mets, Cubs and Dodgers, although I think both the Cardinals and Diamondbacks are dangerous sleepers. …

I'm on the edge of my seat.

The Phillies' Jayson Werth gets better every year. It's time he gets more than 418 at-bats, the career high he set last year. 

Cuz Phil says so.  His measured measuredness determines that Jayson Werth is now good.  Not that he is now actually good.

… Since starting the spring 1-16-3, the pitching thin Houston Astros have won six in a row. The turn-around came after Ivan Rodriguez arrived. … 

He played in three of those games.  But his presence, the mere presence of Ivan Rodriguez won those other three.  He's The Most Interesting Man In The World.  

Go sell stupid someplace else.  We're all booked up here. 

Don't look now but the Yankees' starting rotation looks ready for a big season. C.C. Sabathia, A.J. Burnett, Chien-Ming Wang, Andy Pettitte and Joba Chamberlain are a combined 7-3 with a 2.98 ERA this spring. … 

Hanley Ramirez is hitting .113 this spring.  My fantasy team is screwed!!!!

The Cubs knew Ricky Nolasco was going to be good; but, no, they didn't know Juan Pierre would be so bad … 

In one season with the Cubs, Juan Pierre put up the same numbers in every statistical category than he did the three years previous.  So...

WHAT?

They got what they thought they were going to get.  And that speaks to the stupidity making the trade in general, not anything to do with how 'bad' Pierre was.  What?  He was all of a sudden going to hit 40 home runs?

If Phil did a mid-week whispers, what leftovers are going to be offered for the Sunday paper?

March 23, 2009

Phil Watch: Twittered


Derrek Lee rips into the WBC selection committee, The US loses to Japan in an ugly game and both teams in town are firming up their lineups.

Phil this week?  Feel-good story about...Scott Eyre.  National.  Baseball.  Writer.  Indeed.

March 16, 2009

Phil Watch: Rat Farts!!!


I started and stopped a Phil Watch offering for Phil's Whispers this weekend.

In the span of one paragraph, he got 42 things wrong.  Well, more like five but still a spectacular word-to-wrongness ratio.

It seemed pointless and repetitive...but then he repeated the stupidity today.

So let's do a double Phil.

Here's Phil's Whispers from Saturday for the Sunday paper:

Imagine the howling if Ervin Santana had blown out his elbow pitching in the World Baseball Classic or if Fernando Perez, Tampa Bay's fourth outfielder, had dislocated his wrist in a WBC game.  But the biggest injuries last week were suffered in spring training games, not the WBC. …

Wrong fact #1:  Santana didn't blow out his elbow.  He has a small tear in his MCL and a decision on TJS was made ASAP and PDQ.  He'll start a throwing program next week, open the season on the DL and pitch through it.  

Wrong fact #2:  Fernando Perez is more like the Rays' 9th outfielder, behind the Gabes Gross and Kapler and Pat Burrell when he's not DHing.

Wrong fact #3:  Biggest injuries?  I see one.  Santana.  And if it happened in the WBC, I'd be pissed.  Click on this linky-type thing where Nate Silver at Baseball Prospectus examined April ERAs after the last WBC.  And then keep it in mind if Jake Peavy, a guy that got entirely spanked around against Puerto Rico, struggles out of the gate and loses trade value.  

You know, look at those actual stats that translate to facts and give perspective.  Those crazy, new-fangled facts guys.  They're ruining baseball for the rest of us.       

With Santana expected to be sidelined all season and Kelvim Escobar iffy after his 2008 shoulder surgery, the Angels probably will need two starters from a group including journeymen Dustin Moseley and Shane Loux (both out of options) and prospects Nick Adenhart and Anthony Ortega. 

Wrong fact #4:  Kelvim Escobar has a conservative projected return date of early June right now.  Not iffy.

Wrong fact #5:  It's Moseley and Adenhart.  Has been for like, ever, brah.  Or a trade.  

See.  A wonderous ratio.

And then, as if Phil has a low opinion of himself and thinks nobody actually reads his work, freakin' repeats it...two days later in the Hardball blog! 

The Angels found out Ervin Santana will need Tommy John surgery, sidelining him for the season less than a month after he agreed to a four-year, $30-million contract. This injury could be more significant than it seems now as the organization's depth has been hurt by a winter in which Francisco Rodriguez, Mark Teixeira and Jon Garland were lost to free agency with only Brian Fuentes arriving as a proven newcomer. 

Ladies and gentlemen...I'd like to announce...the RETURN OF PHIL-MATH!!!! 

(thunderous applause)

And on the first day of shirtless driving season?  What is this?  Christmas?

They lost three "proven" veterans and only added one...

Let's play Phil's game and pretend this makes any sense in this world.  Kinda like if we were talking with a 4 year-old about what a zebra and giraffe baby would look like.  Let's play.

THEY ADDED BOBBY FUCKING ABREU!!!!

Like a month ago!  What?  He's not a "proven veteran."

And Phil's raging hard-on for Garland's pitching badness continues!

Now, onto Santana.  He had two days to evaluate his Tommy John surgery wrongness and then repeats it, like it's a foregone conclusion.  It's not and, as of right now, he won't.  It's a slight tear that doesn't necessitate the surgery.  Tons of pitchers have pitched effectively with the same severity of said tear.  Cripes! 

With Carlos Silva and Erik Bedard showing signs of bouncing back, Seattle could join Oakland and maybe even Texas in have at least a shot to catch Mike Scioscia's AL West powerhouse. The difference between the four organizations would be less except for the edge the Angels get from Scioscia. No other manager in the division has ever taken a team to the post-season.

Carlos Silva has thrown 11 innings (0.82 ERA) in the WBC and Bedard has thrown 4 innings (0.00 ERA) in Spring Training.

So let's use Phil logic, because it's fun.  If such a small sample size is a predictor of things to come, then Ken Griffey, Jr. will hit .524 and OPS 1.631 for the Mariners this year, because that's what he's hitting in the WBC this year.

Phil is apparently writing to try to mitigate the disasters of past columns.  He drooled over the Silva signing last year and Carlos went out and promptly posted prodigious numbers like a 4-15 record with a 6.46 ERA and a 1.60 WHIP.

I expect similar Jeremy Affeldt and Frank Thomas columns before the spring is over.

Heck, I totally forgot how much Phil put stock in Spring Training numbers.  Wait, not just Spring Training numbers.  The first quarter of Spring Training numbers.  How about we just simplify it further.  Anyone who hits a homer in Spring Training automatically gets an Opening Day roster spot.  Screw all this thoughtful evaluation process stuff.

March 10, 2009

Phil Watch: Phil Needs "A Changing Of The Pants"


Update con un lado de ca-ca:  Yet.  Another.  

Update:  We have another one!  Curtis Granderson's enthusiasm is so infectious in the WBC that he should take over for Bud Selig when he retires.  Selig's got to be chaffing.  That's a lot of hummers.
 

Bud must be putting out more frequently as of late because Phil's certainly returning the favor.

Boy, the new digs are quite nice here at the new Phil Watch headquarters.

It even has Take Five candy bars in the vending machine.  Now that's fancy.  Big fan.  Big.  Fan!

It's too bad we couldn't roll out the new website, TV deal and merchandising to a little bigger fanfare.

Since our new launch two weeks ago, Phil has been all World Baseball Classic, all the time, just chockablock with quotes from American baseball players throwing around phases like "playoff atmosphere" and "it's real special."  Somehow, this constitutes multiple columns.

You can get it here, here, here and here.

I've said it once, I'll say it again.  Why would I pay for this crap?  I don't care if it's only $.75. 

But let's do one of them, just to bridge the gap between his WBC ramblings and whenever he gets back to telling us that Sam Fuld's Spring Training statistics are a harbinger of scrappy-type goodness to come. 

Whoa, Canada

TORONTO -- Needing two more victories to advance out of the first round, Canada rolled the dice against Italy on Monday night.

Starting Vince Perkins rather than Toronto Blue Jays right-hander Scott Richmond, manager Ernie Whitt was left starting at snake eyes. An experience that had been such a pleasure in 2006, when Canada knocked off the United States in the first round of the World Baseball Classic, had turned into a staggering disappointment.


"Staggering the likes of which we've never seen!"

Oh, on the meatball front, Canadian fans booed the image of Ryan Dempster in a montage that played on the Jumbotron before the game with the United States.  

Just want to put that out there.  Meatballs are multinational.  

Italy jumped on Perkins in the first inning, setting the tone for a 6-2 upset that eliminated the host team in Pool C of the WBC.

"Jumped on" is not the way to describe it.  I watched the game.  Yes, I've seen four WBC games, as the MLB Network plays them around the clock.  Late at night, it's been either that or BC Battles:  Hannibal on the History Channel.  I chose baseball.

And let me tell you.  Perkins blew.  The entire game was like watching the 1991 Camanche Indians play the back end of a doubleheader after two straight doubleheaders in the two days previous.  The pitchin's a little tttthhhhiiiinnnn!

16 walks, wild pitches, huge pitch counts, errors that weren't called errors.  

And the topper?  12,411 showed up in Toronto to watch a Canada team still completely alive in the pool.  They just had to beat Italy and then beat Venezuela to advance.

Canada has World Baseball Classic fever!!!  Catch it!!!

On a related note, I'm typing this as Boers & Bernstein are ripping Phil a new one.  Christo hearts synergy.   

Perkins, a former Joliet Jackhammer who has signed a minor-league contract with the Cubs... 

Dippy Chicago connection.  Phil's right on schedule.

muffed a Nick Punto tapper leading off the first. It was a sign of nerves that continued throughout the long night for Canada, which almost upset the United States in the WBC opener on Saturday.

Nerves?  Looked like plain old badness to me.  As Grandpa Sinkey used to say, "The guy couldn't hit a dead donkey ass if it was two feet in front of him."

Perkins will have trouble winning a roster spot at Triple-A Iowa if his work on Monday was an indication of things to come. He allowed three runs in two innings, largely because of four walks.

The Cubs were going to bring him up but those two innings in the WBC?  Cut his ass.  If he can't get up for a Canada-Italy rivalry, he has no place in baseball.

Jason Grilli, a former White Sox right-hander, worked the final 3 1/3 innings to pitch the inspired Italians into a Tuesday night rematch against Venezuela. The winner will advance alongside the United States to the WBC semifinal in Miami.

Phil, you can keep using words like 'inspired' but it won't make it any more true.  The game was ugly and seen by nobody.  

More people were at the Timberwolves-Wizards game last night.  More people thought watching bad basketball and paying four times the price to watch bad basketball was a better option in Minnesota than watching manufactured international baseball wonderfulness in Toronto.

Venezuela must like its chances. It beat Italy 7-0 in the first round on Saturday.

But unlike Saturday, it cannot go with its top pitchers. Felix Hernandez and Carlos Silva worked eight innings in that first-round game, and Armando Galarraga started against the U.S. on Sunday. That leaves either Ramon Ramirez or Enrique Gonzalez to start against the Italians.


Wait...I'm checking...yep...that's the 12,411th time Phil has told us about Venezuela's pitching quandry.  Coincidentally, that's the same amount of people that saw the latest edition of the historic Canada-Italy rivalry so, I guess not too many times, really.

Italy's victory was unexpected, as the Canadian lineup included the likes of Justin Morneau, Jason Bay, Joey Votto, Russell Martin and Matt Stairs. But Oakland Athletics outfielder Chris Denorfia went 4-for-4 to highlight a victory that included a series of excellent fielding plays -- including a diving catch by Denorfia in center -- to help pitchers who threw strikes.

Let me illustrate how agonizingly boring this game was with a number - 349.  That's how many pitches were thrown in the game.  349!!!  201 were strikes.  It was 3 1/2 hours of bad baseball.

Dan Serafini, who pitched for the Cubs in 1999 but most recently has been working in Mexico, started for Italy. He was followed by lefty Chris Cooper, one of the best pitchers in Italy's top league, and Grilli.

There.  Why do I care?  Essentially, most of the teams are populated with journeymen or guys well past their prime.  I can go to some Independent League game and get that.

And pool play is merely cute.  I don't want to hear Phil bitch about a five-game first round playoff series again when this is seen as a good way to set up an international competition. 

WBC injury update:  Chipper Jones has a strained right oblique and Alfredo Amezega tweaked his knee.

On another note, Mexico played South Africa yesterday in Mexico City.  

Attendance?  10,311.

Catch!  It!

February 22, 2009

Phil Watch: He Said It Was Inarguable


Sit back and relax. Grab a soda, maybe a sandwich. We're going to be here awhile.

I think it's going to be the longest Phil Watch ever.

It's been a bit tough to keep up with the Proustian prose and Norman Mailerian output of Phil this last week.

Heck, we've had four entirely unoriginal columns from Phil on Alex Rodriguez just in the last ten days alone. Apparently he didn't feel heard the first time, second or third time.

But Crede was signed by the Twins two days ago so, as usual, Phil takes what should have been a perfunctory column about Crede's value, age, back issues, defense and World Series memories, brings it to stupid-ass heights and proudly declares him a game and division changer.

Let's get started.

You can argue that Joe Crede has been the White Sox's best ballplayer since he arrived in Chicago to stay in 2002. The point is inarguable since 2005, when Magglio Ordonez fled to Detroit for reasons of money and health.

Shit! Bustin' out of the gate! Direct, efficient and absolutely wrong. Two for three but that third one's always a stickler. Fucking truth. Always muckin' me shit up.

Let's look:

2005

Crede: 96 OPS+ (100 is league average), 2.1 Value Wins, .252/.303/.454
Konerko: 136 OPS+, 4.0 Value Wins, .283/.375/.534
Dye: 118 OPS+, 2.5 Value Wins, .274/.333/.512

The term 'ballplayer' that Phil uses isn't accidental. He's trying to be all sly and shit by insinuating that Crede's defense made up for any offensive shortcomings in any given year.

In 2005, Crede's UZR/150 was a pedestrian 6.2 for someone considered a borderline great defensive third baseman. In fact, it regressed from the year before in what should have been during his prime age years. Also, Value Wins factors in defense.

Verdict: Not only arguable, but wrong.

2006

A healthy Crede had a fantastic year in 2006. Really. Just a great freakin' year for him. But...

Crede: 107 OPS+, 4.1 Value Wins, 20.0 VORP .283/.323/.506
Thome: 155 OPS+, 4.7 Value Wins, 62.7 VORP .288/.416/.598
Dye: 151 OPS+, 3.2 Value Wins, 64.5 VORP .315/.385/.622

Look at the VsORP. Putting Thome aside for a second, Dye had a ridiculously good offensive year in 2006. If he had been a league average fielder that year, he would have generated 5.6 Value Wins, something that would have put him in the top 5 in the league. Value Wins figures a player's total output in every phase of the game with positional adjustment, fielding and replacement value relative to every other player in the league. It's very effectively trying to build a better beast.

Now, Thome put up 4.7 Value Wins even with the positional adjustment of DH taking 1.4 runs off that total. Thome played a full season in the field with the Phillies in 2004, playing just above league-average (1.8). Take his physical ailments into account and aging, he would have sinked below league average if he would have played first base for the Sox that year. Still...he did play a half-win better than Crede in 2006 and if he had played first, he would have played close to two wins better, with everything factored in.

Verdict: Entirely arguable and I go with Thome.

2007

The first two years of Phil's little 2005-2008-Crede-Is-The-Best-Sox-Ballplayer argument were not only arguable but pretty much wrong.

2007 is as rotten as dumpster juice poured over a nice piece of wagyu.

Crede: 49 OPS+, 0.1 Value Wins, -11.0 VORP .216/.258/.317

I'm not even doing comparables. Those are abysmal by any standard when it comes to standardized standarding standards.

But hey, he had a 23.9 UZR/150...in 46 games.

Verdict: Wrong in the wrongest way that wrong can be possibly wrong.

2008

Crede: 98 OPS+, 1.9 Value Wins, 6.2 VORP .248/.314/.460
Quentin: 148 OPS+, 4.7 Value Wins, 51.3 VORP .288/.394/.571

Thome had 2.2 Value Wins and Dye had 1.8 last year. Now, Crede had a spectacular April and June in 2008. In fact, I would argue that what Crede did in April helped the team that was a question mark get through what was considered a tough part of the schedule at the time.

But c'mon. Quentin was Quentin last year. 51.3 VORP vs. 6.2. The Sox were a .500 at best without him.

Verdict: Wrong, wrong and wrong with a side of wrong.

SO...a cogent argument, though not by me, could be made for 2006 only. And I didn't even do pitchers.

But with the other years...



...With Crede migrating from the defending champion Sox, the Twins become favorites to win their fifth division title in eight seasons under the brilliantly simple Ron Gardenhire. They could move into the status of clear favorites if general manager Bill Smith finishes a second deal he's been working on for weeks — a sign-and-trade deal to acquire free-agent reliever Juan Cruz without losing his second-round pick.

We know that Phil has the new Baseball Prospectus handbook (or a website subscription). He's been belching out statistics from the site anytime he needs something to back up his musings all spring training.

In fact, just yesterday, in one of his 8,000 columns on A-Rod, he told us:
Baseball Prospectus assigns Rodriguez a 46.1 VORP (Value Over Replacement Player) rating. That's higher than either of the heralded newcomers, CC Sabathia (43.6) and Mark Teixeira (38.5).
Do you know what the guys at BP 'assigned' Crede? 1.0 VORP. One. With a ceiling of 2.7.

So according to BP, Crede will contribute one run above a replacement player next year with a ceiling of 2.7 runs over a replacement player output, offensively (VORP doesn't take into account defense). Not league-average. Replacement level. A team populated with replacement-level players would win 25 games on average over a 162-game season.

So...Crede is essentially a replacement player offensively with his defense being the X-factor. He's coming off two back surgeries so you can't, with any degree of certainty, predict that he will be the same defensive player he was before the injury. Heck, you can't even really predict defense for a healthy player with any degree of accuracy.

To wit: Aramis Ramirez, throughout his career, has repeatedly put up fielding run numbers in the negatives. Inexplicably, he had 11 fielding runs in 2007, a number that surpasses every fielding run total Crede has ever produced except 2006 (15.6 FR).

You make sense of that and I'll give ya a little sum'un-sum'un.

The fact is you can only ballpark defense with a good sample size and demonstrated health (bad will most likely be bad and good will probably be good with a decent sample size). But even then, it's a fairly big potential production range.

Phil doesn't cherry-pick, though. Fuck VORP when it gums up the works. Did I mention Crede's projected VORP was 1.0?

Twins officials downplayed Sunday the chance of acquiring Cruz. Perhaps they were still in shock after actually seeing Crede in a Minnesota uniform.

Holy Shit! Joe Crede's in camp! I'm speechless! Where are the disciples? I'm a huge Bartholomew fan!

BTW, here's the comparables for Crede that BP compiled:

I don't know about you, but I shit my pants every time Steve Buechele walks into a room. And Ed Sprague? For-get it.

Before signing Crede, the Twins had done almost nothing this winter. Smith pursued Casey Blake unsuccessfully while adding only Luis Ayala and knuckleballer R.A. Dickey.

So...the signing of...Crede...makes them the...favorites? And Juan Cruz makes them...clear favorites?

But the signing of Crede, along with Nick Punto's move from third base to shortstop, should give the Twins the kind of solid infield that once backed Brad Radke, Johan Santana, Kenny Rogers and a young Kyle Lohse.

Heck yeah! Add Crede's 1.0 VORP to Nick Punto's -3.9 VORP and you've got yourself a stew goin'.

Third base, like power hitting, had been one of the White Sox's regular edges over Minnesota. The last time Crede was outplayed by a Twins third baseman was 2004, when Corey Koskie hit 25 home runs. But the measure of Crede has always been his glove as much as clutch hitting.

There's no such thing as a clutch hitter, Phil. Seriously, look it up. I'll have an entire post on this soon, right after the BRE TOA 3, brought to you by VUUUUUUCCCCC!

It's entirely random. There is clutch hitting, to be observed after the fact. "Team X was a great clutch-hitting team last year." But you can't say a particular player is a clutch hitter year in and year out. Seriously, pick any random player and check out all the relevant clutch-hitting statistics over the course of his career. They're typically right in line with his overall production and vary wildly year to year.

Crede's averages by year (RISP, 2-out RISP, Late & Close, September)

2005: .286 .232 .289 .371
2006: .343 .351 .237 .179
2007: .298 .292 .296 DNP
2008: .271 .190 .220 .250 (1-4)

He's all over the map. Take 2006 out of the equation, the year Crede was at the absolutely prime production age of 28, and he was pretty average, only better in relation to himself. That doesn't make him a clutch hitter when he's a below average offensive player overall. It's just making up for his crappiness by being less crappy. And that's no way to go through life.

While Crede was limited to 97 games by recurring back problems, he and the other Sox third basemen, Josh Fields and the also-departed Juan Uribe, had a league-high 378 assists last season, 73 more than Minnesota got from Brian Buscher and six other third basemen. Mark Buehrle figures that number would have been higher had Crede been able to go the distance.

Do the Twins get to sign Fields and Uribe as well?

Oh, and Phil's using assists? They also had the second-most total chances, 80 more than league-average (coincidently, the Twins were league-average) and committed the most errors (33) with Crede booting 20 of them in 'limited action' last year.

With agent Scott Boras setting a year-at-a-time contract pace, Crede never had a multiyear deal with the Sox. He would have been in line for a big contract this winter if not for the back injury, which limited him to 144 games over the last two years.

I know! Teams are just throwing money around this year! It's insane. Look at all the money a guy Baseball Prospectus says will have a VORP 22 times greater than Crede got.

C'mon. What would a team give a 31 year-old third baseman with a career .306 OBP and 98 OPS+...even without the back injury...even not taking this economy into account.

What? 4 years/$40 million? Big money?

What the point of all the speculation anyway?

Crede without a bad back is a guy you want on your team at a reasonable price, especially if he learns to walk more as he ages. Absolutely. I don't hate Joe Crede.

But in this realm, on this Earth, in this time, on this temporal plane, Joe Crede has a bad back.

Because of Crede's back, as well as the availability of possible replacements in Fields, Dayan Viciedo and Gordon Beckham, his departure hasn't caused as much angst for Sox fans as it may have. They see almost all players as disposable parts, in part because Ozzie Guillen produced a championship in the first season after the loss of Ordonez and Carlos Lee.

Disposable? Has Phil ever talked to a Sox fan? I got into a debate with one last year because he thought Nick Masset was untouchable. (Cripes, a ton of them bemoaned the loss of Uribe. This same shit happened after the Angels won the series in '02. Everybody was untouchable, even if they sucked stinky chicken ass. But I digress.)

Ordonez, another Boras client, suffered a knee injury in 2004 that allowed him to play only 52 games. It severely damaged his free-agent value the next winter, but Boras put together a creative deal with the Detroit Tigers, who have gotten 73 home runs and 346 RBIs from Ordonez the last three years. He played only 82 games in '05 but has since raised his average to 135 games since leaving Chicago.

I've seen Magglio Ordoñez, watched him play, seen his statistics. Mr. Crede, you are no Magglio Ordoñez.

Boras believes Crede can make an even better comeback, with a second surgery last fall finishing the repair that the one in 2007 started. The artificial turf at the Metrodome won't be ideal, but Boras doesn't expect it to be a major issue.

Well shit, if Boras says so.

And on to Phil. 'Isn't ideal' is what Phil offers today. Just three weeks ago, Phil offered this:
The Twins continue to talk to Joe Crede, but would 81 home games on turf make sense for a guy with back problems? He'd be a better fit in San Francisco or Houston.
What's changed in three weeks? Oh, we here at Phil Watch remember, Phil. Even when you don't.

If Crede stays on the field, he will make the Twins better. They were essentially intact after winning 88 games a year ago, so if they are better they have to be the favorites.

Okay. The Twins are a fine little team. And Crede's a fine little addition with moderate upside. But regressing to the mean may be the mantra in the Twin Cities this year.

They hit .305 with runners in scoring position last year, nearly 20 points higher than the next-best team. Heck, they hit 26 points higher than the two teams - Cubs and Angels - that won the most games in each league last year. Ain't happening again, my peeps.

They hit .276 the year before with largely the same lineup, .296 in 2006 and .271 in 2005.

See! Clutch-hitting is not predictive and largely random.

You. Don't. Bank. On. It.

February 15, 2009

Phil Watch: Only Cuz It's About The Angels


It's encouraging that Phil got himself a subscription to Baseball Prospectus. It's not encouraging that he's chosen to barely use it.

C'mon. Dig in there, Phil. Dig in there.

Let's get started.

While the White Sox grappled with the knowledge that baseball's leading think tank had pegged them to go from first to worst in the American League Central, the chronically underachieving Los Angeles Angels reacted to an ugly projection of their own. According to Baseball Prospectus, they were poised to finish behind Oakland, failing to win the AL West for only the second time in six years.

Okay. Here's the thing. The reason the Angels won 100 games last year was because they played in the crap hole that is the AL West. They went 26-12 against the Rangers and Mariners last year combined, 10-9 against the A's. It's entirely reasonable to think those records will be repeated, leaving them 15 games over .500 again this year against their division.

The Angels also get the pleasure of playing the NL West in interleague play this year. Last year, they went 6-3 against the NL East. Again, entirely reasonable to think they can repeat that against the NL West. That's now 18 games over .500. If the team goes .500 against the rest of the AL - again, entirely reasonable given the weird off-season - they're 90-72.

I don't doubt the minds at BP - baseball minds greater than mine - but I think they undershot the individual expected performances of the Angels this year, especially w/r/t offense. I think they erred on the side of caution given the fact that so many first-year players and young players coming off injuries are expected to play.

Unlike the Sox, the Angels opted to do some last-minute shopping from the bargain bin, and they're going to be glad they did. General manager Tony Reagins didn't say no when Bobby Abreu fell into his lap and quickly made up the Angels' perceived deficit.

Yes. Reagins only made the move once the PECOTA computer projections told him he needed to.

The BP computer adjusted the Angels from 80 to 84 victories, which is enough to make Mike Scioscia's team again a division favorite, if not by as wide a margin as you would think.

The surprise wasn't that the Angels won't win 100 games again. I was that PECOTA had them under .500. So who's 'you', Phil. You? High 80s in wins was probably expected by every reasonable Angels fan with the Rangers and Mariners once again diligently holding themselves to the position of not fielding a competitive team.

The Angels won 100 games last season and have averaged 94 victories over the last five seasons. But they are at least somewhat vulnerable in the mild, mild West after losing Mark Teixeira, Francisco Rodriguez, Jon Garland and Garret Anderson.

Technically, the Angels had a better winning percentage without Teixeira last year (.662 vs. .617).

The team will have a better bullpen without Frankie this year. Book it.

Jon Garland? How will they replace his 4.90 ERA? Or his 5.99 ERA after the break? The horror!

Rivera replaced Anderson before the Abreu signing. $20 bet on who performs better this year. Now, Abreu replaces Anderson. $100,000 bet on who performs better this year.

However, their lineup looks a lot better with the talented Abreu in left field rather than a mix of Terry Evans, Reggie Willits, Juan Rivera and Gary Matthews Jr. It's hard to believe you can get a potential 100 runs-100 RBIs guy for $5 million and incentives, but Abreu simply had slipped between the cracks.

Terry Evans? Listed first? Cripes!

They just signed Rivera to a $13 million deal to play left and DH!

Terry Evans won't even sniff the majors this year on any regular basis. Not a whiff. It's obvious that Phil WENT to Baseball Prospectus. They don't even have Evans getting one at-bat. Terry Evans? It would be like telling a Sox fan that Donny Lucy will see time behind the plate this year and you would say, "Who?" and I would say, "Exactly."

Abreu, who'll turn 35 in March, had a .371 on-base percentage and stole 22 bases to go along with 20 home runs last season. He figures to be on base regularly when Vladimir Guerrero hits, as Scioscia's most likely batting order has Abreu second, Guerrero third and Torii Hunter fourth.

Phil says this because Mike DiGiovanna of the LA Times said it two days ago. At least he kept it in the family.

Now, I know Scioscia has talked about it and it's probably the "plan" entering spring training but it won't be the case by mid-April. Kendrick's a prototypical #2 hitter and will hit there. It's probably motivational crap to get Kendrick to feel a bit marginalized and have him realize that taking a walk and staying healthy is a good thing.

It's Figgins, Kendrick, Abreu, Guerrero, Hunter, Rivera, Napoli, Morales and Aybar. Book it.

"I'll like hitting in front of Vladdy," Abreu said. "My type of game specifically is to be on base and score some runs. I still have my speed."

See. Nothing that says the two-hole specifically. Just 'in front of Vladdy' (God, I hate all the Angels' nicknames. Every one is shortened by half with a 'y' on the end. Thanks, Rex Hudler. Dope.)

The signing of the left-handed-hitting Abreu addressed an imbalance. The Angels hit 11 points higher against left-handers than right-handers last year and were tilting even more in that direction without Anderson and Teixeira.

This one's oddly constructed. Every team in baseball has this type of split for the most part. Anderson is left-handed and typically hit both evenly. Teixeira was an Angel for two freakin' months. There was no dramatic disparity among the LHB v. RH, RHB v. LH, blah, blah, blah.
All hovered in the .260-.270 range. Oh, there is one. The BABIP for LHB v. LH (small size) and LHB in general was above .290 typical, meaning some luck was involved. Therefore, not really relevant.

Just say they needed a middle-of-the-order guy who is left-handed. There. Done. All the other left-handed hitting options before Abreu were switch-hitting slap hitters. See. Easy.

Like Milwaukee's signing of Braden Looper, this was a good move. Those two made a lot more sense than last week's other big free-agent signing — the two-year deal that Adam Dunn took from Washington.

Dunn wanted to play for a contender. The Cubs had been his first choice, but he turned to Houston after the Milton Bradley signing. He would have helped the Astros, but GM Ed Wade couldn't scare up the money to make it happen.


I agree. Houston better be on the verge of bankruptcy because a signing of Dunn and a decent #3 starter would have absolutely put them right in the mix in the Central. For hardly any money, they would have been a contender. It's inexplicable. Wolf and Dunn would have cost the team $15 million this year according to the contracts they signed. Ugh. Just hand the Cubs the division. It's not like the Cardinals are doing anything smart. They signed Kyle freakin' Lohse for four years at $10 million a year!

I wonder if Phil will mention that sort of stupidity regarding Lohse, Phil's pet baby last Spring Training.

One last nugget.

On Milwaukee signing Braden Looper:

Melvin hopes Looper enjoys the home clubhouse at Miller Park more than he did the visiting clubhouse. He has a mark of 0-4 with a 7.01 ERA in 252/3 innings in the retractable-roof stadium.

Where to begin? When Looper pitched in Milwaukee in the past, he faced batters that wore a Brewers uniform unless I'm mistaken and there are secret games being played behind my back.

Now, I guess it's possible that Looper's karma doesn't translate in Wisconsin. Or maybe he doesn't like the restaurant selection in the city or a particular Brewer fan continuously gives him a hard time and it hurts his feelings.

But park stats for pitchers don't translate when he goes to that team because he's not facing players that knocked the shit out of him in the past.

So when Looper takes the mound this year in a Milwaukee uniform, he will never have to face Ryan Braun, Prince Fielder, Rickie Weeks, Corey Hart and J.J. Hardy.

Why those five guys? Because they've hit a combined .441 off Looper.

Just a thought.

January 25, 2009

Phil Watch: I Don't Know Where To Begin


Anyone ever have a wildly irresponsible friend?

You know, the kind of guy who gets drunk and tries to jump off the roof of the apartment just to see if he can do it without breaking his leg.

And this friend on occasion - say every three years or so - asks to borrow your car to see if he can drive to Midway and back in an hour to, you know, just see if can do it.

And every three years or so you have say, "Hell no!"

He counters with "What's going to happen? You can't predict accidents. You could get into an accident tomorrow!"

And you have to sit him down like he's a five year-old and tell him, "That's the difference, little one. It's my car...and I'm driving. If something happens, it's going to be on me, not because I gave the keys to some dope who's bored and wants to prove how big his dick is."

That's what Phil seems to be missing when ripping into John Danks for passing on the World Baseball Classic today.

Seriously, this is why people don't read newspapers anymore.

Let's get started.

White Sox fans are very proud of John Danks. He declined the chance to play for the U.S. in the World Baseball Classic, saying he wants to make sure he's prepared for the 2009 season.

This is a very popular position for him to take, but it raises a couple of questions:

• Why can't a 23-year-old in great shape make two or three starts in March, working with strict pitch limits and extreme caution, without risking his readiness for the season?

• Why would the U.S. want Danks in the first place?

Let's see. Danks just completed a season where he pitched 40 more innings than he has ever thrown and is coming into a season where the Sox are going to rely on him heavily with the back of the rotation so up in the air.

I know! He should skip the bulk of Spring Training with the Sox and go play in some dippy Bug Selig creation with absolutely no point just because he can. Let's hand the keys to your brand-new car to someone else. Why not?

Phil's first question begs another question. If every player in the "Classic" is going to have to be treated with kid gloves, then why do it? It's not even a real game. It's cutesy bullshit.

Phil's second question begs a "Huh?"

He's a good pitcher and a tough competitor with a great future. Every major-league team would want to have him on its roster. But he has had one strong season in the big leagues. Does that qualify him to represent his country?

Love it! "Represent his country," like it's some Olympian honor where people train their whole lives just for the miniscule chance to compete in something that will most likely define the rest of their lives.

That's what this is NOT!

Who'd a thunk it? Phil has taken a position on the World Baseball Classic that's even more idiotic than anything Rick Telander could offer. It's like Telander on crack, chockablock with dreamy, pie-eyed international wonderfulness.

What about CC Sabathia? Or Brandon Webb? Or at least a half-dozen others, such as Cole Hamels, Tim Lincecum, Roy Halladay, Derek Lowe, John Lackey and Cliff Lee?

Or Mickey Morandini? Or Lenny Dykstra?

You take any four of those eight guys, you have a serious staff, a real All-Star team, the kind of team that was envisioned when Commissioner Bud Selig and his staffers dreamed up the WBC.

Yes. The kind of ideas that come from dreams. Then you wake up, give it ten minutes and realize that idea was borderline retarded.

But unfortunately, major-league dugouts and front offices are populated by far too many short-sighted, self-interested players and executives.

Yeah. God forbid try to protect your investment. That's just stupid business sense.

Notice that Phil hasn't told us WHY the WBC is remotely a good idea yet?

The second edition of the WBC gets here in March, three years after the inaugural, in which the U.S. went 3-3 and failed to advance to the four-team final round.

That was such a blow to my patriotism. I felt like less of an American that day.

Once again the U.S. has put together a team lacking the bulk of American talent, limiting the possible success of the event before it even begins.

Can this country take another blow to its already diminished status around the world?

Sabathia, Webb and those other six starting pitchers are among the huge group of American stars who didn't submit their names for inclusion on the provisional roster or whose names were pulled back before the roster was released.

Sabathia pitched 40,000 innings last year and just signed a 40 year deal worth 40 bazillion dollars. The Yankees should allow him to run out there on the mother of all short rests for no real reason.

That plan is flawless! This isn't play money, Phil. It's real, like money that can buy stuff.

...The guys who are eager to play, like the Cubs' Derrek Lee and the White Sox's Matt Thornton, deserve credit for getting it.

Derrek Lee and Matt Thornton are better Americans than C.C. Sabathia and Brandon Webb.

Traitors. Somebody call Michelle Bachmann.

The WBC should be a welcome break from the drudgery of spring training. It's surprising that more players don't look at it like this.

My God, Phil. Just have sex for Selig and get it over with.

Phil here alludes to complaints on the part of some players recently that Spring Training is too long, which it probably is.

Congratulations. He just gave reason #10,659 why NOT to extend the preseason with kitschy little 'World Competitions'. To be game-ready (or what is supposed to approximate 'game-ready' for for this crap), position players have to start training two weeks earlier than usual and pitchers would need three. You know...to be stupid-ass "Classic"-ready.

It is supposed to be real games, right? Not time for pitchers to work on specific pitches and hone their location like Spring Training games are, right?

Freakin' great plan.

...Bottom line: Baseball players shouldn't be afraid to play baseball.

Thems fightin' words.

Derrek Lee = Rambo. Webb = Aldrich Ames.

I nominate this column as a top fiver in the Phil anthology, behind recommending the Rays sign Barry Bonds because it would be fun to see him hit in Fenway but ahead of the entire column dedicated to the wonders of Jeremy Affeldt.


Phil was a voluminous little fucker again this Sunday with no mid-week columns.

His second long-form offering discusses the sale of the Cubs to the Ricketts family. It gives nothing in the way of substance outside of recapping the obvious with a few dippy Cub fan '100 year' jokes thrown in.

But here's two nuggets:

If Ricketts wanted, he could find a big role in his organization (president or whatever title you want) for a baseball savant like recently retired general manager Pat Gillick. Or, if he wanted to try something really progressive, Greg Maddux, who figures to get bored playing golf. Those guys would represent the club and help Jim Hendry and his strong front-office staff in setting a vision for the operation.

That way, when Phil achieves immaculate conception and has Greg Maddux's baby, he'll be closer for family time.

President. Greg Maddux. Jus cuz he's all Cubbie and shit.

...(discussing the renovation of Wrigley Field) For this to happen, the Cubs may have to shift a season's worth of games to U.S. Cellular Field and possibly even Milwaukee's Miller Park—and the sooner the better. Why not get the work done in time for the 2014 season, allowing fans to celebrate Wrigley's 100th anniversary in a much-improved park?

The Cubs should rearrange theirs and two other teams' entire schedules because 100 is a round number. It's pretty. Oh, so pretty.

Cub fan to the core. Phil. You are my muse.

January 18, 2009

Phil Watch: Mishmash Of Mucky Muck


Ever watch a movie and think it was fine enough as the credits rolled? And then you get into the car and realize, "Holy Crap, that movie sucked!"

It comes from being able to step back a bit and see it's suckitude in all it's glory.

We'll call it the Burn After Reading effect.

Phil's column today has it. Boy, does it have it. It's Phil's Whispers. He has his ear to the ground for us, people.

Let's get started.

How committed are the Cubs to Ryan Theriot as their shortstop? There was never even internal discussion about pursuing Michael Young, who the Rangers made available after he balked at moving to third base.

Yes. Ryan Theriot's diminutive wonderfulness is what stopped Hendry from talking about Michael Young. Not the fact that the Cubs are about to be sold and Young has a contract that pays him $16 million each year for the next five years. Yes. Not that. It's Ryan Theriot and all his throwback greatness to the 30s and 40s.

Young and the Rangers appear to have worked out their differences, meaning it's Hank Blalock the Rangers are trying to trade. …Blalock's availability doesn't help the market for Joe Crede, who is among the large group of free agents still unsigned. …

Yes. A team should trade a couple of decent to good minor leaguers for Blalock and pick up his $6.25 million contract for 2009 instead of signing Joe Crede to an incentive-laden one year deal worth $5 million with an option. Yes. That's the way teams should operate. Give up something or somethings for Blalock, a guy who also hasn't played a full season since 2006. Phil = Consistent.

Also unsigned is a large group that was offered arbitration and declined it, including Orlando Cabrera, Ben Sheets, Juan Cruz, Jon Garland, Brandon Lyon and Oliver Perez. Brewers GM Doug Melvin said he considered signing Cruz as his closer but opted for Trevor Hoffman because he didn't want to give up a first-round draft pick. …

Phil. Sweety. Melvin was being nice. If he let it all fly, Melvin would have said that Cruz has been a decent middle reliever over the last two years, has a WHIP that says it's been a bit of a mirage and HAS NEVER CLOSED! Yes. Give up a first round draft pick for that.

Spring training sleeper for the Cubs—center fielder Sam Fuld, who has had a big winter in Venezuela and has leadoff man skills. For the White Sox—third baseman Javier Castillo, a non-roster invitee who hit .288 between Double-A Birmingham and Triple-A Charlotte last season. …

Cripes! That's the 48 bazillionth time he's mentioned Sam freakin' Fuld's "big" winter in the freakin' Venezuelan league. Please tell me how Fuld gets into the lineup to lead off. Please. No answer has been given yet. Cubs outfield: Soriano, Bradley, Fukudome, Johnson, Gathright. And man, if Fuld breaks camp with the Cubs, they're quickly becoming a nugget convention with Theriot, Fontenot and him.

Javier Castillo? A light-hitting third basemen with a career .266 minor league average, doesn't walk and is a little too booty? Fuck Viciedo and Fields. He's is The Answer!

The Brewers are interested in free-agent starter Braden Looper.

Early 2009 nomination for the most irrelevant sentence ever written ever.


And then there's Phil's flagship Sunday column.

...Both Reinsdorf and McCourt keep a close eye on the bottom line. While Reinsdorf took the White Sox's payroll into the nine-digit stratosphere in the honeymoon seasons after the 2005 championship, he and general manager Ken Williams now appear ahead of the curve in watching out for the economic downturn facing baseball and other professional sports.

Nine-digit stratosphere? It was $103 million, good for 4th in baseball...after a World freakin' Championship. Now...I'm thinking that Phil believes that kind of spending is bad given the word choice and the fact that he wrote 4,000 columns in 2008 about the White Sox irresponsible spending. Let's see who this plays out.

And they're not 'ahead of the curve'. Has Phil been watching this offseason? Not one team will enter 2009 with a payroll higher than 2008. Not one. Not even the Yankees.

The White Sox opened 2008 with a payroll of $121.2 million and added to it by trading for Ken Griffey Jr. at the trading deadline. The signing of Bartolo Colon gave them 14 players signed at $83.525 million. Factoring in the arbitration-eligible Bobby Jenks and 10 entry-level players, they will be in the range of $92-94 million when the season opens—and they are still open to trading Jermaine Dye, which could lower that figure.

So that's pretty good...right?

The movement to get younger—creating opportunity for players like Josh Fields, Dayan Viciedo, Chris Getz, Brian Anderson, Jerry Owens and Brent Lillibridge—is allowing the White Sox to cut almost $30 million off the payroll, seemingly without being passed by anyone in the American League Central.

So...really good...right?

The Dodgers' cost-cutting is even worse, as Manny Ramirez can testify. The reality with a situation almost as strange as Ramirez himself is that it now appears the Dodgers never really wanted to re-sign Ramirez. Many around baseball believe general manager Ned Colletti made Ramirez a two-year offer only to save face, with the expectation that somebody would outbid him. But that hasn't happened.

Worse? Probably poor word choice. But...worse?

And so...now we have the Dodgers NOT signing Manny. They're NOT signing him in Phil's world for the reasons given.

If the Dodgers really wanted to keep Ramirez, they would have done it by now. But whispers have gone around for years about McCourt not having the usual financial muscle of Dodgers' owners, and that is being borne out this winter.

So again...there's NOT signing Manny...in Phil's world...for the 12,000 reasons given.

...The Dodgers opened the 2008 season with a payroll of $118.6 million, and added Ramirez, Casey Blake and Greg Maddux in midseason deals. But they since have released Andruw Jones, lost six free agents to other teams (most notably Derek Lowe and Brad Penny) and allowed eight others, including Ramirez, to linger unsigned.

So...they're...cutting...payrolllllll. And no Manny...?

They have only about $52 million committed to nine players, with two of the three biggest contracts belonging to players who haven't helped ( Juan Pierre and Jason Schmidt). They have four arbitration-eligible players, including catcher Russell Martin and closer Jonathan Broxton, and are expected eventually to re-sign Ramirez.

JEBUS H. CHRIST!!!! YOU JUST SAID THEY'RE NOT GOING TO SIGN MANNY!!!!!!!!

While the Sox count on production from inexpensive contributors like Carlos Quentin, Alexei Ramirez, John Danks and Gavin Floyd, the Dodgers have a deeper, more touted core of young players. Matt Kemp, Andre Ethier, James Loney and Martin figure to hit together near the middle of the order for years to come.

De-Bat-Able. Matt Kemp looks like a monkey humping a football when he plays the outfield. Loney hasn't developed anything resembling consistent power yet (except against the Cubs in the playoffs, of course. Tee-hee.) and Ethier? Meh. We'll see. They were a .500 team last year in a shit-ass division before trading for Manny.

Chad Billingsley, Clayton Kershaw, James McDonald and Cory Wade similarly anchor the pitching staff (although Billingsley may not be ready to open 2009 because of a November broken leg, when he slipped on ice).

Anchor?

Billingsley = Good. Yes.

Kershaw = Should be decent. Great hook. Had some control issues.

McDonald = Six major league innings. Six.

Wade = Never started a major league game. Never.

And where the hell is Kuroda?

Gee whiz, Phil. Two guys have no major league starting experience, one is coming off an injury and the other is primed to go through growing pains. How is that 'anchoring' anything?

But can you cut your payroll 30 percent and defend a division title? The Dodgers, like the White Sox, hope the answer is yes.

Well...it kind of depending on what that 30 percent is, doesn't it? Just a thought.